?

Log in

 
 
23 September 2011 @ 01:59 pm
Challenge 12 Voting!  
Voting for Challenge 12 is under the cut. A HUGE thank you to everyone who participated in this round-you all did a rocking job and I really do hope you join us for round 6. I encourage ALL members to vote, but please note narniacmr & visionsbeyond cannot vote. Good luck!

Voting rules:
1. Vote for your favorite in each section.
2. Reasons are optional.
3. Don't vote for yourself or get people to vote for you!
4. You can post your icons after results are announced.
5. Votes will be unscreened after voting ends.
6. Voting ends on Sunday, September 25th at 8 pm EST, but will be extended if necessary.


You can copy the text area and paste it to your comment.


Part One-Geometric Shapes
001
002
 


Part Two-Faceless
003
004
 


Part Three-Aerial
005
006
 


Part Four-One Image / 2 icons
007
008
009
010
 


Part Five- Promo Banner with icon
11.

12.

Poll #1780991 round 05 final

Part 1

01
7(58.3%)
02
5(41.7%)

Part 2

03
8(66.7%)
04
4(33.3%)

Part 3

05
6(50.0%)
06
6(50.0%)

Part 4-vote for 2 icons

07
1(4.3%)
08
9(39.1%)
09
10(43.5%)
10
3(13.0%)

Part 5

11
0(0.0%)
12
12(100.0%)
 
 
 
My Inner Sanctum: my inner sanctum betrayedmy_innersanctum on September 24th, 2011 02:12 am (UTC)
cl r5 ch12 voting
Part One-Geometric Shapes
001: Fave: The images all work well together, especially with respect to color.
002: Least Fave: Though the idea is a good one, the cut out seems out of place in this icon.

Part Two-Faceless
003: Fave
004: Least Fave: the texture makes the icon too busy.

Part Three-Aerial
005: Least Fave
006: Fave: the negative space works well with the icon.

Part Four-One Image / 2 icons
007/008: Least Fave: the intensity of the pink in the first overwhelms the icon.
009/010: Fave: The cropping and image quality make both these icons.

Part Five- Promo Banner with icon
011: Least Fave: The intense blue color overwhelms the icon and banner.
012: Fave